Many sources claim that mobile (3G/4G/5G) proxies are significantly better than residential ones, especially for scraping tasks. Yet if you think about it, they don’t have any obvious technical advantages: the connection is less stable, speed can fluctuate depending on a huge number of factors you can’t control, response time can reach embarrassingly high values, and they are more expensive than any other type of proxy. It’s hard to argue with all that, and yet mobile proxies still remain the best option.
In this article, we’ll break everything down so you understand why and when mobile 4G proxies are the top, no-alternative solution.
Mobile 4G proxies are proxies that run on devices connected to the Internet via fourth-generation mobile networks: smartphones, tablets, modems, mobile routers, and so on.
4G (Fourth Generation) is a general term for a whole set of technologies that underpin mobile internet: frequency bands, special antenna formats, protocols, etc. But the main things we need to know in the context of this article are:
As a result, because a large number of independent clients (hundreds or even thousands) can in reality be working behind a single mobile operator IP, security systems treat mobile connections with maximum caution – putting such an IP address on a blacklist could affect many innocent users. Blocking a mobile IP is like shooting yourself in the foot.
For this reason, mobile 4G proxies don’t so much look “more real” as they are effectively forced to be ignored by anti-fraud systems and WAFs. From this follows an important conclusion: the most trusted proxies for web scraping are mobile ones. And this “trust factor” outweighs all the other drawbacks of mobile 4G proxies: speed drops, random disconnects, and so on.
Advantages and disadvantages of mobile proxies.
By classic residential proxies, we usually mean proxies that operate in home user networks (here we’re talking about both real and fake residential proxies). In other words, their IP addresses belong to home internet providers. Although strictly speaking, mobile proxies could also be classified as residential, since a proxy on a mobile device runs as a resident application.
Nevertheless, because of everything described above, it makes sense to treat mobile 4G proxies as a separate group.
If we compare residential proxies to mobile ones head-to-head, we can highlight the following key differences:
Comparison table: Residential vs mobile proxies
|
Criterion |
Residential Proxies |
Mobile Proxies (4G/5G) |
|
IP Type |
Home ISPs |
Mobile operators |
|
Website trust level |
High |
Maximum |
|
IP Rotation |
Rare, depends on the ISP |
Frequent, natural (due to CG-NAT) |
|
Resistance to anti-bot systems |
Good |
Maximum |
|
Speed and stability |
Stable and higher than mobile |
Fluctuating, depends on the network |
|
Risk of blocking |
Medium |
Minimum |
|
Type of possible blocking |
At the level of a specific user IP (if the ISP uses “clean” dynamic addresses) |
At the level of an entire subnet (due to CG-NAT) |
|
Cost |
Medium |
Higher |
|
Best use cases |
Large-scale scraping without strict protections, high-speed, and high-volume tasks |
Social networks, marketplaces, and services with strict anti-bot filters |
Advantages and disadvantages of residential proxies.
Mobile proxies move to the forefront for web scraping when you’re running into advanced protection systems too often. In other words, when you need to work with A-class web services and sites: social networks, search engines, marketplaces, and the like.
But it’s important to remember that mobile 4G/5G proxies solve only one part of the puzzle – they increase trust and reduce the risk of being blocked. They do not guarantee a 100% success rate. Because of this, it’s crucial to build the rest of your scraping strategy and mechanisms properly.
Below, we’ll go over the key nuances.
It’s important to remember that when you’re using web scraping proxies over a mobile connection, the IP can change without any action on your side – simply due to the specifics of internal routing. Still, you should try to keep the connection alive as long as possible when this matters for building trust and for the task at hand. The clearest example is working with data after logging into an account. If you use rotation based on the “one request – one IP” principle, the anti-fraud system will very quickly block the entire account.
Therefore, to add “naturalness,” it’s important not only to work correctly with cookies, CSRF tokens, and other digital fingerprint attributes, but also to try to obtain new mobile 4G proxies during automatic rotation from the same provider’s network, in the same city/location, and ideally with the same ASN number. By default, it makes sense to choose sticky sessions here. They will be held for as long as technically possible.
Even if IPs do change, it will look like a user naturally moving between base stations or just dynamic rotation managed by the PGW / PDN-Gateway. This won’t attract much attention from protection systems.
At the same time, if you’re working with a target site without authorization, a more logical approach is to rotate proxies for web scraping with every new request or on a short time interval. That way, multiple connections and a large volume of typical requests can remain unnoticed. From the protection systems’ point of view, these will look like new, independent visits from different clients and devices. But it’s important to remember that a site can still identify users by cookies and other attributes. So, along with IP rotation, you also need to rotate the digital fingerprint (browser profile).
Most major mobile proxy providers offer the following rotation options:
As for the logic of selecting new addresses, this can be:
Premium mobile IPs for ultimate flexibility and seamless connectivity.
The most common mistake is treating mobile 4G proxies the same way as server-side proxies. No real mobile client can send a large volume of requests in a short period of time. Be patient and use natural delays, including randomized pauses.
You also need to be extremely careful with cookies, the user agent, and other digital fingerprint attributes. If you’re connecting through a mobile proxy server, the client parameters should look appropriate: the browser should identify itself as mobile, have a matching screen/window resolution, and so on.
More on how to scrape without getting blocked.
As mentioned above, mobile 4G proxies have their own specifics: they are expensive and unstable. This naturally introduces certain risks. But if you understand those risks, you can plan a strategy to mitigate them.
For example, to minimize costs, you can use pay-as-you-go billing or purchase small traffic packages (strictly aligned with your actual consumption). What you definitely shouldn’t do is save money by choosing low-quality proxies – they’ll suffer from poor stability and low connection speeds, which will nullify all their advantages.
Connection stability can be smoothed out through the right rotation logic. It’s enough to choose a proxy service with reverse connection (backconnect proxies). In that case, proxies are connected to the scraper only once, and rotation and replacement of exit IPs fall entirely under the provider’s responsibility. For the client, this process is invisible.
For working with large traffic volumes where maximum connection stability is critical, it’s worth considering server (datacenter) or residential (home) proxies instead.
Advantages and disadvantages of server/datacenter proxies.
Situations where mobile 4G proxies will be most effective:
Connecting through mobile 4G proxies is perceived by protection systems as completely natural, especially if the creator of the scraper has taken care to mimic realistic digital fingerprints and chosen the right location for the exit IP address.
But even if an anti-fraud system suspects something, it will most likely avoid taking drastic measures, simply because of how mobile networks are built: hundreds or even thousands of real users can be working behind the same IP address at the same time.
Mobile 4G/5G proxies do have their drawbacks – they’re expensive and can randomly “drop” the connection. You can work around these disadvantages by choosing a quality provider with fair pricing, convenient billing, reliable proxies, and a backconnect setup.
Want to rent rotating mobile proxies with maximum comfort? Choose Froxy. We have over 10 million IPs in our pool, precise targeting, flexible session duration and rotation options, and traffic package billing with rollover of unused volume.